Welcome to The New Haven Pizza Co
The New Haven Pizza Co, located in Wolcott, CT, is a culinary gem that captures the essence of classic New Haven-style pizza. Patrons rave about the crisp crust, flavorful sauce, and generous toppings, making pizzas like their pepperoni and sausage a must-try. Beyond pizza, the menu dazzles with homemade meatballs, stuffed shells, and unique offerings like baked stuffed shrimp pizza. The warm, accommodating staff and inviting atmosphere enhance the dining experience. Whether you're savoring fried mozzarella or the exquisite Chicken Francaise, every dish reflects a commitment to quality and flavor. A visit here promises an exceptional taste of Italian comfort food.
-
747 Wolcott Rd, Wolcott, CT 06716, United States Hotline: +1 203-879-8800
Welcome to The New Haven Pizza Co, a culinary gem nestled at 747 Wolcott Rd in Wolcott, CT. This brick oven pizzeria brings a taste of authentic New Haven-style pizza right to your neighborhood. Known for its crisp crust, flavorful sauces, and a bounty of fresh toppings, The New Haven Pizza Co promises that every slice will captivate your palate.
Many patrons, like James Nobitz, have traveled from various parts of Connecticut only to discover this hidden treasure. He's raved about their large cheese pizza topped with bacon and meatballs, noting the exceptional quality of the mozzarella and the delightful fried mozzarella served with marinara—an absolute must-try! It's clear from his enthusiasm that whether you're craving classic flavors or adventurous combinations, The New Haven Pizza Co has something to satisfy every pizza lover's heart.
But pizza is just the beginning. As Matt B. shared, the menu goes beyond traditional pies; stuffed shells and homemade meatballs find their way into the hearts—and stomachs—of the pickiest eaters. With choices like cauliflower crust and stuffed shrimp pizza, even those with dietary preferences will find delicious options. Families are returning repeatedly, drawn not only by the food but by the accommodating staff who treat every guest like family.
The dine-in experience is equally remarkable. Customers like Tammy Worth have sung praises about the attentive service and pleasing atmosphere, sharing that every order is met with care. Whether you’re savoring their sausage, mushrooms, and onions pizza or indulging in a chicken parmesan grinder, the flavors will make you feel at home.
For those new to the area, Angelica Jackson's experience reflects the sentiment of many: after moving to Wolcott, she and her husband found a pizza that exceeded their expectations. The half pepperoni and half anchovies pizza vanished before they could take a picture—proof that good food doesn’t last long. Their passionate reviews echo the satisfaction found across the board, making The New Haven Pizza Co a veritable haven for pizza aficionados.
So, if you find yourself in Wolcott, be sure to visit The New Haven Pizza Co. It’s more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a community hub that brings people together over delicious, high-quality food. From its charming ambiance to the delectable dishes await, prepare for a memorable dining experience that challenges your idea of what pizza should be.
Oh boy! I recently moved from Fairfield County Connecticut to Hartford County, specifically Bristol. I have been looking for a really good pizza joint, I grew up eating great pizza from New Haven to Bridgeport, unfortunately being in Bristol for 6 months I have been disappointed time after time. Well that has ended today! The New Haven Pizza Company in Wolcott is EXCELLENT! Just a beautiful 6 mile drive away. Whenever I try a new place my eyes are always bigger then my stomach and I get excited and really want to try everything on the menu lol. But for my first visit I got a large cheese pizza, half bacon half meatball...I love this pizza! Crust was crisp, sauce is flavorful, plenty of toppings, great mozzarella cheese. Fried mozzarella was incredible...2 big triangles of cheese covered in marinara sauce, this delicious and I will order often. Finally I got a chicken parm on a hard roll...Excellent! Not many places have a choice of a hard roll or grinder roll, I had to get a hard roll because when I worked in New Haven I got that for lunch almost everyday. Will get this again. Unfortunately I didn't see any deserts on the menu otherwise I would have gotten something sweet. Trust me when I tell you if you like New Haven style pizza or NY style pizza, you will love this place. Thank goodness I don't live next door to this place or I'd weigh 500 pounds. Enjoy!
Food is honestly amazing. From the stuffed shells, to their homemade meatballs; their cauliflower crust is awesome, and so is their stuffed shrimp pizza. Sounded weird to me and everyone said I must try it..: wow... they were right!! We are guilty of eating here 4 times in past 9 days . My kids love it and I’m PICKY with pizza and Italian food especially growing up in Connecticut. Great place and the staff is always accommodating. Thank you
Love this place for pizza. Brick oven style too.. wasn't suprising that there was a wait for take out... i truly do appreciate the fact that when we called in the order there was no sugar coating the wait time... staff always very sweet, attentive, friendly also very helpful and accommodating. Especially since i like little side items like sauce to dip my crust in... Thank you for another wonderful pie.. And for cooking for us.... lol... We had sausage, mushrooms and onion this time... yummy.... Of course my king of spice added crushed red pepper.. opted for no franks hot sauce on this one lol.... I do enjoy parmesan cheese on my sauce...
Was visiting family and I was recommended this place. We ordered a pepperoni and sausage pizza and calamari. The pizza was so tasty and yummy. Loved the calamari as well. Very prompt and courteous service.
We always go for their baked stuff shrimp pizza. Our favorite and very delicious
Amazing food and atmosphere. From the wings, to the chicken parmesan grinder to the baked stuffed shrimp pizza, and so many of my other favorites. But the best part of it all is the staff! so kind and accommodating. Dining here is a MUST!
This pizza is excellent!! My husband and I just moved to Wolcott a month ago and have yet to find decent pizza in the area. Him being from NY is very particular about the type of pizza he eats. Standing ovation from us!! We ate it all before we were able to take a photo! But we ordered a large 1/2 pepperoni and 1/2 anchovies. We will be back.
We came in after 8pm. They were wonderful as we expressed we knew it was late and they went above and beyond to make sure we were taken care of. The Chicken Francaise is one of the best I had! And it’s my go to dish. Flavor was spot on and the chicken cut beautifully with a fork. My husband’s pizza was excellent.